Back to Testimonies

Stories from the Street

Once Saved, Always Saved?

November 3, 2026

This report comes from team leader Mark with our Eastern Market team in Detroit, MI:

I often evangelize at Eastern Market, a large farmer’s market in Detroit. However, nobody else was available to join me at the market last Saturday so I joined the nearby Plymouth team for their outing. We went to Kellogg Park, a small but popular park in the middle of town. We met many young families, older couples, and teenagers who gathered to enjoy a warm, sunny day in downtown Plymouth.

Our longest and most impactful conversation was with a sixty-something man named Bob. He was a Jehovah’s Witness for a long time but left that organization several years ago and now tries to bring other people out of it. Bob hasn’t felt at-home in any church and has some doctrinal issues with his current Protestant congregation. He said that he cannot accept the teaching of “once saved, always saved.” Bob said that it is both unbiblical and illogical to believe that your salvation is secure. I told him that it is the sin of presumption to continue to sin without repentance and assume that God will forgive you.

Bob had a couple of misunderstandings and disagreements with Catholic beliefs. He couldn’t accept the intercession of saints and veneration of Our Lady. We talked about Mary’s Fiat and her role as Mother of God. I talked about the distinctions between latria, hyperdulia, and dulia. I referenced “All generations will call me blessed (Luke 1:48)” and also how Jesus performed His first miracle at the request of the Blessed Virgin Mary. I also talked about how, in most ancient cultures, including ancient Israel, the queen was the mother of the king, not one of the king’s wives.

We talked with Bob for probably twenty minutes. In the end, he wasn’t fully convinced but he definitely had a better understanding of the reasons behind our beliefs. He accepted a necklace with Miraculous Medal and crucifix, as well as several pamphlets. I pointed out our website on the back of each pamphlet and encouraged him to follow-up with us.

Praised be Jesus Christ!